The Motorist guide to car transmissions in malaysia: what’s the difference?

When choosing a car in Malaysia, the type of transmission you select can greatly affect your driving experience. Not only does each transmission type work differently, but they also feel unique when you're behind the wheel. Below, we delve into the pros and cons of each transmission type, how to drive them smoothly, and how they feel when driving.

1. Manual Transmission (MT)

How It Works:
A manual transmission requires the driver to use a clutch pedal and gear stick to manually change gears. The driver controls when and how the car shifts gears based on speed and engine demands.

Pros:

• Lower Cost: Typically cheaper to purchase and maintain.

• Durability: Known for longevity when maintained properly.

• Driver Engagement: Offers a more hands-on driving experience.

Cons:

• Traffic Fatigue: Repeated gear shifting can be tiring in stop-and-go traffic.

• Learning Curve: Requires skill to operate smoothly.

• Limited Availability: Fewer modern cars now offer manual options.
  
  

How It Feels When Driven:
Driving a manual is often described as more engaging and rewarding, especially for car enthusiasts like I am. The car responds directly to your inputs, giving you more control over acceleration and deceleration. You'll feel a connection to the car as you row through the gears and manage the clutch. However, in heavy traffic, frequent clutch use and gear shifting can become tiring and cumbersome, leading to a less relaxed driving experience.

Tips for Driving Smoothly:

• Avoid Riding the Clutch: Keep your foot off the clutch when not shifting to prevent
  unnecessary wear.

• Smooth Shifting: Release the clutch slowly while applying throttle to ensure smooth 
  gear changes.

• Rev Match: Bump the throttle to match engine speed with the transmission speed for 
  smooth gear changes and less wear on clutch.

• Anticipate Stops: Press the clutch when coming to a stop to avoid stalling.

Cars in Malaysia with Manual Transmission:

• Perodua Saga 1.3 Standard Manual

• Toyota GT86 

• Mazda MX-5

• Honda Civic Type R (FL5)

2. Automatic Transmission (AT)

How It Works:
An automatic transmission uses a torque converter to automatically change gears based on engine speed and load, providing a smoother driving experience without the need for the driver to engage the clutch.

Pros:

• Convenience: Ideal for city traffic, especially in congested areas.

• Wide Availability: Found in most cars available in Malaysia.

• Smooth Driving: Offers a more relaxed and easy driving experience.

• Reliability: Torque Converter automatics are quite resilient and don’t break often.

Cons:

• Higher Costs: Automatics are typically more expensive to purchase and repair.

• Fuel Efficiency: Older models may be less fuel-efficient than manual transmissions.

• Reduced Control: Less involvement in driving compared to a manual.
  
  

How It Feels When Driven:
Automatic transmissions are known for their ease of use. In urban settings with lots of stop-and-go traffic, automatics excel, offering a stress-free drive without the need to shift gears manually. While this ease of driving is one of the main benefits, some drivers feel it lacks the engagement or responsiveness of a manual transmission, making it less exciting for those who enjoy more dynamic driving. However, there are some examples of torque converter automatic transmissions making their way onto sports cars (2024 Nissan Z and Toyota GR86) but those are quite rare and tuned to be more engaging.

Tips for Driving Smoothly:

• Avoid Sudden Shifts: Always come to a complete stop before shifting from "Reverse" 
  to "Drive."

• Smooth Inputs: Gradually give your pedals input instead of just stomping them every 
  time.
  
  

Cars in Malaysia with Automatic Transmission:

• Toyota Camry

• Honda Accord

• Mazda 3

• BMW 3 Series

3. Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT)

How It Works:
A CVT uses a belt and pulley system to provide an infinite range of gear ratios. This allows the engine to stay at the most efficient speed for any given situation, delivering a smooth and seamless driving experience.

Pros:

• Fuel Efficiency: Optimizes fuel consumption, particularly in city driving.

• Smooth Acceleration: Provides uninterrupted acceleration without gear shifts.

• Widely Avaliable: Available in most cars in Malaysia

• Inching in Traffic: Best transmission for inching forward in traffic.

Cons:

• Rubber-Band Effect: Delay in power once you put your foot down.

• No Gears: Some drivers find the lack of traditional gear shifts disorienting.

• Performance Limitations: Not ideal for high-performance driving or steep hills.

• Drone Noise: CVT’s have a trademark drone sound when accelerating, which can be 
  annoying for drivers.

• Expensive fixes: CVTs are complex and cost a fortune to fix.
  
  

How It Feels When Driven:
A CVT provides a smooth, almost “effortless” driving experience. The engine revs up steadily without the noticeable “shift points” you get with traditional gear systems, giving the car a sensation of constant, uninterrupted acceleration. While this is great for fuel efficiency and driving comfort in traffic, this is the bane of any car enthusiast’s existence as they're notoriously boring to drive. For the average joe though, this is the perfect transmission for saving fuel, comfort and going around the city.

Tips for Driving Smoothly:

• Accelerate Gradually: This can reduce the drone noise slightly.

• Avoid Launching the Car: Launching your car at a traffic light or from a stop can cause
  severe wear and tear on the belt of the transmission.

• Avoid Overrevving the Car: High revs (4k above) can cause heat to build up on the belt
  and cause wear and tear.

Cars in Malaysia with CVT:

• Toyota Vios

• Nissan Almera

• Honda City

• Perodua Myvi

4. Dual-Clutch Transmission (DCT)

How It Works:
A dual-clutch transmission uses two separate clutches for odd and even gears, allowing for rapid gear shifts. DCTs provide smooth, almost instantaneous gear changes, making them ideal for performance-driven vehicles. However, they can be found in economy cars too for the fuel efficiency and the versatility it brings for the driver.

Pros:

• Quick Gear Changes: Gear shifts happen almost instantly, accelerations feel more 
  smoother compared to AMT’s and Manuals.

• Fuel Efficiency: Often more efficient than traditional automatics.

• Sporty Feel: Provides a highly responsive and engaging driving experience

• Versatility: Can be manual or automatic according to the driver’s preference.

Cons:

• Expensive Repairs: Due to the complexity of the system, maintenance can be costly.

• Low-Speed Jerks: In stop-and-go traffic, the dual-clutch can feel jerky, especially during 
  low-speed shifts.

• Durability Concerns: Older dual-clutch systems have had reliability issues, although 
  modern versions have improved.

• Heat: Overheating can be a concern for DCTs as their clutch packs can produce a lot 
  of heat. 

How It Feels When Driven:
Although DCTs are a type of automatic transmission, driving a car with a DCT feels sharp and responsive. Gear shifts are almost instantaneous, which gives the car a sporty, "race car-like" feel. However, at lower speeds (like in traffic), some DCTs can feel jerky, as they struggle to smoothly manage shifts at low revs. On highways or during quick acceleration, however, the shifts feel crisp and powerful, making the driving experience very dynamic.

Tips for Driving Smoothly:

• Be Gentle with the Pedal: Smooth acceleration and deceleration help avoid jerks at low 
  speeds.

• Don’t inch Forward: Inching forward slowly in traffic isn’t advised here as the DCT can’t 
  engage into first gear due to low speeds, generating unnecessary heat and wear.

Cars in Malaysia with DCT:

• Porsche 911

• Proton X70 Premium

• McLaren 750s

• Volkswagen Golf GTI

• BMW M2 (F87)

Conclusion: How Each Transmission Feels on the Road

Choosing the right transmission not only affects how a car performs but also how it feels when driving. Manual transmissions offer a more involved and engaging experience but can be tiring in traffic. Automatics provide ease of access and hassle free drives but can be uninspiring. CVTs offer seamless acceleration with excellent fuel efficiency but it can be fragile if not taken care of. Dual-clutch transmissions are sporty and quick but can be less smooth in slow-moving traffic.

By understanding how each transmission type works and how it feels when driven, you can make a more informed choice and enjoy a better driving experience in Malaysia, whether you're navigating city streets or hitting the open highway.

Looking to buy or sell your car? Download Motorist Malaysia's app now to find the perfect used car with the right transmission for you.

Read More: Here’s How To Keep Your Engine and Tyres in Tip-Top Shape!

Download the Motorist App now. Designed by drivers for drivers, this all-in-one app lets you receive the latest traffic updates, gives you access to live traffic cameras, and helps you manage vehicle related matters.